Release of the annual reports of the Social Security and Medicare Trustees last week was met with resounding hallelujahs. It was as though our nation’s fiscal problems were declared officially over.
In a prominent cheer, Paul Krugman in the New York Times announced that “The Geezers Are All Right.” Various news stories portrayed the campaign for a budget “grand bargain” to be dead.
I don’t see it quite that way. I will concede that the prospects for a fiscal deal in Washington are perhaps even a little more dead than they were before the reports. But the good news in the Trustees’ reports goes no further than buying Washington a little more time – and perhaps not as much time as Washington needs to head off the ultimate, unavoidable (as even Krugman acknowledges) Social Security and Medicare problem.
To start with a broad overview of the reaction: What you see in the mirror of the Trustees’ reports depends heavily on who you are – and in particular, what you believe about the meaning of the Social Security and Medicare Trust Funds. The people who reacted most positively and strongly to the reports were those who believe that Social Security and Medicare can pay their benefit obligations with their trust funds, and the full-faith-and-credit Treasury special certificates in those funds. Those who reacted most skeptically believe that the assets in those trust funds cannot costlessly be realized to meet the benefit obligations of those programs.